Blog 1 – Kassie Lerman

On Tuesday we participated in a class discussion regarding Lorde’s, “Age, Race, Class and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.” While the reading itself was very interesting on its own, it was also fascinating to discuss it in its relation to games. The reading discusses Lorde’s experiences of being part of multiple minority groups. She mentions not only the struggles she faced as a minority but also the issues she faced within her own minority group.

One of the issues mentioned is that Lorde’s belonging to the LGBTQ community caused some tension with those in the black community. How there was a general consensus on the correct way to be black and being a lesbian was not the correct way. One of my group members brought up an interesting parallel in the gaming community. In the gaming community, sometimes there is a determined “correct” way to play a game or there is the “normal” gamer and if you deviate you open yourself up to harassment and ostracization from the community. This has a large effect in the gaming community, for example, casual players feeling they have no place because they don’t dedicate more time to the games or they aren’t “real” gamers and also a lot of female gamers try and hid their female identity to fit in more with what a gamer should be. This reading, along with the class discussion on the mythical “normal,” lead to a very engaging class discussion.

Sources: Lorde, Audre. “Reading Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.” Sister Outsider, 1984. Pg 114-123

Shijia Zheng Blog Post 1

With the rise of Twine to create interactive media, there has been debate over what is and isn’t a “real game.” Although I see Twine media as something akin to a game, there are others that believe otherwise. For sure, when many people discuss games and even genres of games, many games of specific mediums or platforms tend to be left out in these discussions due to the fact that they believe those games of a certain type “do not count”. What can and can’t be defined as games have always been fuzzy. Is it the amount of visuals involved? The amount of interactive freedom given to the user dictated as the “player?” The competitive component? Many media classified as games can be negative for one of the above questions (i.e. Detroit: Become Human lacks a competitive component), and media that are debated to be games can be positive for all of them (as per the Twine example, many Twine-based RPGs are positive for all three questions). In my opinion, if the creator believes that what they have created is a game, then it should count as such. 

In addition, while some media are classified as “games”, they are seen as inherently inferior based on the medium or platform of the game. Games designed to be played in browser or mobile platforms are often looked down upon as only for “casual” people and games of good quality cannot be found there. Although, as someone who frequents these platforms, I would debate otherwise, as I have found many enjoyable games through those platforms.

The desire from groups of people to count out media as “real games” and the exclusion of “inferior” games in discussions seem synonymous with Lorde’s accounts in “Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.” She discusses her experiences in the Black community where lesbian women are seen as anti-Black because lesbianism is seen as a “white women’s problem” (Lorde, 8). This can be seen as synonymous to some people excluding Twine games as “real games” as well as the exclusion of games of certain mediums and platforms, such as browser and mobile games, in genre discussions such as indie games. While these games may be different from the popular definition of games, it is still important to include them in gaming discussions to include a new point of view.

Sources:Lorde. Age, Race, Class and Sex: Women Redefining Difference. Sister Outsider.

Blog 2

On the Tuesday lecture one interesting point is we went through a tool called twine, it’s a hands on web application that allow us to learn how to create our own game. One interesting game created from twine is called queers in love at the end of the world, it’s created by Anna Anthropy, be honest with you guys, I never though that a game can be this creative, at the beginning I was so confuse about this game, we have a ten minute timer on the clock running down, and on the player experience part, we feel rushed when playing this game, we really got the real feeling of we only have 10 seconds in our life and we have to make quick choices, it will be the first choice that came up in our mind with in our conscious. And we learn that by setting up constraints in the game such as, 10 second timer, really have a huge impact on the mechanics of the game.

Later on in the class we have a chance to choose a board game to play with our classmates. We choose Catan, we look though some procedural rhetoric of the board game. For example we figure out that in Catan, roll of dice represent the unpredictable circumstances of life, you can not control what resources you getting anytime, but there is another aspect, you can place your settlement on the resources that with high probability so you can get the most distinct resources you get, also when you rolled the number 7 on dice you can rob someones resources, this play style makes the game fair, prevent one player from overpowering one certain resources.

DMS 462 Blog Post #1

One topic I found interesting during this week was from our class discussion on the reading Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference by Andre Lorde. In the article, the author talks about how differences between genders and race are causing distortions and dehumanizing between groups, particularly for women of color. I find this very intriguing because we’re reading this from the perspective of someone who’s deeply affected on oppression and separation, and representing a whole community against other groups. It also states how we grow up letting these definitions and labels influence us, and not thinking about the negatives until it becomes apparent. Lorde mentions that if we don’t pass on what we know and ignore the differences, “the younger members of a community view the older members as contemptible or suspect or excess, they will never be able to join hands… nor ask the all-important question, “Why?” (117). I find this to be true because it does feels like we’re taught to be accepted, you have to fit in or to feel above others. The thought of being raised to behave and love/hate certain people without question is starting to become reality as we’re diversifying more than ever. This part about growing up educated in diversity stood out to me because it wasn’t until attending university that I learn more in depth about race, gender and sexism. If we were to educate early and differently, would our environments be better and equal? Would this eliminate oppression, differences and sexism if it were taught at a young age?

Overall, I thought this reading was very insightful, as it gave us a smaller picture in a bigger problem. I usually see this struggle in oppression and equality between white people and others of color, but I now realize that there are also differences within groups that need solving as well. In the article, Lorde says “Our future survival is predicated upon our ability to relate within equality… we must recognize differences among women who are our equals, neither inferior nor superior, and devise ways to use each other’s difference to enrich our visions and our joint struggles” (122). From what the article shows us, in order to put aside our differences and join, we fist must acknowledge them and abandon old definitions that won’t serve anything but cause separation.

Works cited

Lorde, Andre. “Reading Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.” Sister Outsider, 1984. Pg 114-123

Ng_Jackie_Blog_2

The idea of a “mythical norm” is one that although I had not heard before this reading was something that felt similar to another term, I had learned previously in a different media course. Audre Lorde describes in Age, Race, Class, Sex: Women Redefining Difference that mythical norm is something that people recognize as “not me [themselves]” and that “it is with this mythical norm that the trappings of power reside within this society” (Lorde 116). What stands out to me is what the implications of the mythical norm is, it being that a mythical; fabricated or non-existent, term is what is supposed to be setting a precedent for what is meant to be “normal,” as if normality could be defined with a single statement.

What mythic norm reminded me of was the term “mythic speech” used within a different course. Myth is something Roland Barthes describes in Mythologies: Myth Today as “a system of communication, that it [myth] is a message. This allows one to perceive that myth cannot possibly be an object, a concept, or an idea, it is a mode of signification, a form” (Barthes 107). I feel these two terms really tie into each other and build upon what a term with “myth” in it means. Barthes speaks about how myth is a form of communication and its presence is signifying something; in the case of Lorde, she is saying that myth in mythic norm is to signify that normality is “white, thin, male, young, heterosexual, Christian, and financially secure (Lorde 116).”

This idea of mythical norm is something that is not only present in gaming, but many other forms of media as well. We are not going to sit here and pretend that the gaming industry is the only offender of this with characters like Doom Guy (by far the most Christian of games and character), Sole Survivor from Fallout 4 (while character customization is available, the game starts the creator as a married white male with a white spouse in house), and though he isn’t exactly Christian nor financially secure in the normal way, Geralt from the Witcher series, when extremely “mythical norm” representatives like Tony Stark, John Wick from John Wick, or Lucifer from Lucifer diverges much from this concept.

Sources

Barthes, Roland. Myths Today.

Lorde, Audre.  Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference

Ng_Jackie_Blog_1

               Robert Ebert’s Video Games Can Never Be Art was a reading that, I will admit, got a reaction out of me. After reading it, there were many things I wanted to discuss about his stance on video games and several things I believe to be misconceptions. Ebert argues the extent of what video games can be before the simply become a “representation” of another medium, and that ultimately what separated video games from what he perceived as art was that games had “rules, points, objectives, and an outcome.” What I personally fail to understand is his next point that when a video game lacks these traits that make them uniquely such, they become a representation of one of several entities he considers art.

                Ebert states that is that games have rules, points, objectives, and an outcome, therefore allowing the audience to “win” that stops the game from being an experience, which is something attributed to art; it is something you can only experience. However, are there not traits which he has associated with games that are also present in story, novels, plays, dance, and films? These are all mediums Ebert believes to be art, not on the basis of emotions evoked, or messages conveyed, but because, from my understanding, they do not require effort nor participation from the viewer in order to experience it. “The only way I could experience joy or ecstasy from her games would be through profit participation.”

                However, do story, novels, plays, dance and film not contain rules, objectives, and outcomes? Though they do not require participation from the viewer, are these traits not essential to the way those art mediums are created. A story, novel, or film with no outcome isn’t much of a complete piece. Rules are also necessary, are grammar, human limitations, and certain requirements (such as sound, or visuals) necessary for certain mediums? Are stories, novels, or film something that are written and created with no objectives in mind? I could argue that there are video games that have no outcomes, nor “winning”, that certain games revolve around the idea of making our own objectives and rules. Do we as the viewer not have to participate, be it mentally (reading, paying attention), or physically (moving, listening, seeing) for other forms of the listed forms of art? Why would games be an exception on the basis that they require more?

Sources

Ebert, Robert. 2010. Video Games Can Never Be Art. Received –  http://www.rogerebert.com/rogers-journal/video-games-can-never-be-art

DMS 462 Blog Post #2 – Timothy Harianja

One the most interesting topics that we had this past week is the one about Audre Lodre’s Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women redefining Difference. In her text, she mainly talks about how differences and how we perceive them affect our lives, for the most part, negatively. In any society, differences are inevitable. Ignorance is usually the main reason why differences separate us, just like what she mentions on page 115, “But it is not those differences between us that are separating us. It is rather our refusal to recognize those differences, and to examine the distortions which result from our misnaming them and their effects upon human behavior and expectations“. After thinking about it, I think this is true to a certain degree because most people tend to stay in their comfort zone and be “ignorant” to anything that they are not used to. Most people grow up according to the mythical norm set in that society. Another problem she mentions in the text is that ignorance to see differences still exist within a group that is fighting for other differences. For example, within a group of woman who fight for woman’s rights, sometimes white women fail to see the differences between them and black women. She also goes on to talk about how men also play a role in this whole situation etc.

While reading her text, I keep thinking ‘This type of issues are apparent in a lot of countries and we have been dealing with this in America for quite long. Will there be any point of time where we reach a decent understanding about differences and not just simply ignore them?’ Maybe yes, or maybe it’s just the nature of who we are. I guess the main key to this problem is acknowledging these differences first. In order to do so, sometimes it requires effort, such as reading article like these or getting to know people who are different to you. I think effort is needed because in reading Lorde’s text, there are a lot of things that she mentions about black women, white women, and men that still seem abstract to me because I never have any first-hand experiences of it. The very least thing that we can do is try to accept and understand these differences.

Lorde, Audre.  Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.  Received from https://learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet01-xythos.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/5e00ea752296c/5328871?response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%2A%3DUTF-8%27%27Lorde-Age-Race-Class-Sex.pdf&response-content-type=application%2Fpdf&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Date=20200206T022754Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=21600&X-Amz-Credential=AKIAZH6WM4PLTYPZRQMY%2F20200206%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Signature=22e1d1f6fa8f59e70fdcfb7571f83c25d59ff18eb34ff6d89d016b41995fd991

Gillian Marcus Blog Post 1

Audre Lorde’s Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference was a very interesting and informative read.  In her text, she talked about the inferiority of women alongside racism, further explaining how black women in particular are even more oppressed due to them experiencing both racism and sexism.  On page 117, she states, “This is a very complex question, but I believe one of the reasons white women have such difficulty reading Black women’s work is because of their reluctance to see Black women as women and different from themselves.”  This is a very strong statement, but I believe Lorde is stating that societal stereotypes prevent white women from seeing black women’s works the same way they might see someone who is white. However, I feel as though her lack of explanation of many of these very complex and strong statements leave me rather confused and interested in the reasoning behind them, such as when she later on in the text discussed how black lesbians are not necessarily seen as black to other black women.  On page 121, she states, “Heterosexual Black women often tend to ignore or discount the existence and work of Black lesbians.” I am intrigued by this statement, as I never knew of this. However, although the focus of the piece seemed to be mostly on colored women in America, it only further goes to show the inequality LGBTQ+ people also experience.

There were also aspects to this text that left me emotional and shocked, such as when Lorde states, “In certain parts of Africa, small girls are still being sewed shut between their legs to keep them docile and for men’s pleasure” (page 120).  I find this absolutely horrifying and disgusting. Women are still treated like objects in many countries today and are even tested that they’re “virgins” before they are married. Additionally, when she stated that women of Color are the lowest paid wage earners in America, I became deeply disturbed with society’s racism and sexism against these innocent individuals who cannot change the way they were born.  Her writing is emotionally evoking and allows readers to truly understand the severity of the situation these individuals are facing and how, even though times are a lot better than the early 1900s, women (especially of color) are still not equal.

Lorde, Audre.  Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.  Received from

The Developer, Players and The Game Post #2

The player is one of the most valued parts of game design. Many developers forget the necessity of their audience because they are either focused on one aspect or their own wants.  This concept is iterated by Fullerton where he says,“It’s far too easy to get caught up in a game’s graphics, story line, or new features (Fullerton, 3).” A game has no utilization without its players. It’s similar to a car without its driver. A car company shouldn’t develop a car with only cosmetics in mind because most likely that car will crash and burn. The player is the end goal and the developer should always be asking themselves about what the player would do and keeping a fresh and open mind when planning their game. The developer can also have the player try the game for themselves instead of being the only ones playing the game. This function is known as playtesting.

Playtesting is one of the key solutions in preventing a game failure. During playtesting, players are able to give feedback on the game and how every aspect affected them during their run. With every new person who tries the game, they add another beneficial addition. This extra puzzle piece to the testing is the complex differences and backgrounds that create the separating experiences between players. However, every person will have their own opinion and therefore a developer will not be able to accommodate all of them. As mentioned in Lorde’s article, it’s essential to acknowledge everyone’s differences. Although when planning, the creator can’t always guarantee every player will love the game and should focus on a certain niche. A game that attempts to please everyone will fail. This idea is similar to the common phrase, you can’t always please everyone. It’s true.

Overall, there are two things that can’t be done. First, one cannot only focus on a specific game feature. Good gameplay should be the objective, but it should have the audience in mind. Secondly, there is no possible way to please everyone. There is no game that every person in the world likes equally. So, when planning, everything should be considered, but within limits and kept moderated.

By: Samantha Reeb

Works Cited

Fullerton, Tracy. Game Design Workshop: a Playcentric Approach to Creating Innovative Games. CRC Press, 2019.

Lorde, Audre. Sister Outsider: Essays and Speeches. Crossing Press, 2007.

Sarah Vazquez’s DMS 462 Blog Post #2

One of the things that have stood out to me the most this week was this idea of the mythical norm.  This term is brought up in “Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference” by Audre Lorde.  Lorde describes the mythical norm, in America, as the person who is “white, thin, young, heterosexual, Christian, and financially secure” (Lorde, 116). She also says that the mythical norm is something that “each one of us within our hearts knows ‘that is not me’” (Lorde 116).  This concept struck my attention because it is something that isn’t real and yet it is the one thing that is highly represented within the games we play.  Instead of gaming industries gearing their characters more toward representing the people who make up the population, it is an over representation of the very thing that no one ever really is.  In a way, we all stand united in the fact that we never truly see ourselves in the protagonist we play within the games we hold close to our hearts.  Honestly, I never really noticed how much this mystical norm is presents within my gaming career.  An example would be Halo. I love most of the Halo franchise (especially the classics made by Bungie), but I can’t deny that Master Chief is a clear representation of this mythical norm.  He is this strong, white, heterosexual, male who is this super soldier.  It is funny how a young girl like myself in the past loved playing this character who was almost everything I wasn’t, and yet I loved playing him so much.  In a way, it is nice to be able to be immersed into a character who is different from yourself.  I just find that not being given an option of who to become, or what kind of character to be immersed with is the problem.  The Last of Us, Dead Space, and so many other games (whether great or not) are examples of games that limit their protagonist to represent this one false idea of what is powerful and ideal.  Many people who play games start playing them at a very young age, and I believe that is the perfect time to open up their horizons to different kinds of heroes and characters.

Works Cited

“Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.” Sister Outsider Essays and Speeches, by Audre Lorde, Ten Speed Press, 2016, pp. 114–123.