Games, Rules, and Play

Play is, by definition, taking part of an activity for enjoyment. Games are a form of play, in which there are a set of rules the players must follow to reach some sort of goal. Every game has different rules that must be followed, and you must be able to understand the rules of the game in order to play. Brian Upton mentions in his article, The Aesthetic of Play, “As long as I take a few minutes to learn the rules, I can play a game that originated in Germany or Ghana, or Peru, or ancient Mesopotamia, and it will function properly for me as a game” (Upton, pg. 9). This quote resonates with me, as I have played and learned to play many games throughout my life, and all it takes is some time to get used to the rules of the game.

One example of this is with Uno. In Uno, your goal is to clear your hand of cards, but some cards hold special properties. You can use a skip card to skip a person’s turn, reverse to change the order of players, and a wild card to change the color. If you have ever played Uno before, these might seem like second nature to you, but for someone who has never played Uno, they might not get it right away. It is only until they learn the rules of the game will they understand that they can put down a card of a different color as long as it’s the same number, or if they put down a plus four wild card, the person next to them will not be happy.

Rules play a very important role in play. Games must enforce the rules in order for the players to enjoy the game and have fun. Some players like to have less rules put on them so they can have as much creativity as possible. Games like Dungeons and Dragons does a great job at giving the player choices and the ability to change the story through their actions. Some players like to play games that are more story focused. Single player video games do a good job at telling a story while also keeping the player interacting with the world they immerse themselves in. People play games differently, and prefer some games over others, but every game has a set of rules and each player must follow the rules in order for the games to function.

Sources:

Upton, Brian. The Aesthetic of Play, 2015

Work VS. Play and the Experience

In this day and age, play is more vibrant than ever. It is present daily. From consoles and PCs to board games, play entertains and wraps around us. In order to play, one’s belief of reality must be cast aside during it, but only enough to remove the seriousness and freely join a new world or setting, known as the magic circle. However, there are forms of play that can be stuck on the border of work and play. Professional gaming can be seen as work. The player is paid and ordered to act a certain way. In the words of Huizinga, “all play is a voluntary activity.” Therefore, that form of gaming is work, but this could be argued. Depending on the person, their job could be voluntary. The person enjoys the play and it is not strictly an order, since they have full willingness to play. If it was truly an order, then perhaps they would quit or no longer enjoy the game. Many major league players start off as regularly enjoying a game, but later on choose it as a job because it could be a source of income. So, there is no clear distinction whether or not professional gaming is considered play.


Play, in relation to one’s culture, has a much stricter and easier relationship to understand. Each person experiences play in a different way. From the example in Upton’s “The Aesthetic of Play” visiting a Chinese opera will not be experienced the same way by a foreigner versus a Chinese citizen who understands all the social, cultural and political history surrounding the opera. Anyone can join a game and play it, but it doesn’t mean everyone will feel the same way. If thought about in regards to race, gender or even age, a game can be sexist, racist or ageist. With that in mind, a game might be acceptable to one group versus another because of the opposing characteristics between groups. A gay man could view a character as homophobic while a straight man could ignore the problematic aspects of that character because they don’t notice those stereotypes that are commonly placed in triple A titles. However, with the increasing publicity of rights of minorities, this will hopefully produce better representation within games and make play a good experience for all.

By: Samantha Reeb

Works Cited

Huizinga, Johan. Homo Ludens: a Study of the Play Element in Culture. Angelico Press, 2016.

Upton, Brian. The Aesthetic of Play. The MIT Press, 2015.

What is a Definition for a game?

Two questioned that we have discussed. What is a definition for a game? Game can be single player or multiplayer, it’s the same concept as sport either basketball or e sport. We spend time alone to improve our mechanics or skill sets needed for the game. On the other hand we can be playing the game together with our friends. The definition for game can be described as insensitive, balance, investment/engagement, Score/Point, Setting/Where the game is played(Basketball Court), interactive, Feeling, Mechanics(Activity), Story, Sound

Gamer Motivation Survey, for my gamer Motivation Profile includes, Aggressive, Persistent, Driven, Social, Grounded, and Inquisitive, this is a survey I took in the class for the purpose of which type of gamer we are.

And later on in the Thursday lecture we read about the Aesthetic of play, We also talk about what is Game, Game are systems, lucrative, social worlds, have/create meaning, also we know that play is outside of culture, you don’t need to learn how to play. More definition about games it is a rule based formal System variable outcomes, there is three part of it, emergence, progression(early game, midgame, lategame), Narrative.

We also talk about what is game designer, think about the player/your audience, for example I am participate in a group called bridges it is a christian organization welcoming international students help them to build a home away from their home country. And I am in charge of the ice breaker game for the event, so my player will be college students, not children, people from all over the world, with different culture, world view background. So when I design the ice breaker for them, just like what it describe in the book Aesthetic of play, you don’t need to learn about the culture to play the game, simply you can just learn the rules and the game is playable, but if we talk about enjoy the game, it’s another story.

Upton, Brian. Aesthetic of Play. Received from https://learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet01-xythos.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/5e00ea752296c/5331553?response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%2A%3DUTF-8%27%27Aesthetic%2520of%2520Play.pdf&response-content-type=application%2Fpdf&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Date=20200202T153629Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=21599&X-Amz-Credential=AKIAZH6WM4PLTYPZRQMY%2F20200202%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Signature=66ee9d40d08a71d31a6e0fe5b5efd2b1eef445620390083ca64e9481d0c70a16

DMS 462 Blog Post #1 – Timothy Harianja

This week, we talked about the nature of play and I think this is an interesting topic to dive in more. I never have thought much about play as much as I have about culture and games. In his book, Brian Upton starts describing play as something that transcends culture. He uses game as an example of play, not to mention that game is not the totality of play. In short, He argues that a person can learn a game and its rules from another culture different to his/her own; furthermore claiming that play is more fundamental than culture.

After putting some thoughts about this, I realized that a person does not have to understand the meaning behind the rules or the cultural context of the game itself to participate in the game. This leads to me thinking that play is not defined by what we feel or how much we feel. It’s defined based on the fact that we participate in the play and we feel something to a certain degree. Later in his book, he mentions “Contained within this definition are four elements that Huizinga believes are fundamental to play: movement, freedom, rules, and boundaries. Play is a process, not a static state of affairs” (Upton, 14). I want to focus on rules and boundaries. I think rules and boundaries are made to define the context in which we feel. For example, in a game of chess, we can capture an opponent’s piece or reach checkmate. Capturing an opponent’s piece creates the feeling of progress and, on the other hand, reaching checkmate creates the feeling of winning or achieving something. We like and enjoy these feelings. Without those rules, we do not get to feel those in a chess game because the players can’t understand the meaning behind a move or an action. Culture seems to emphasize those feelings in game. Even I have experienced this when I moved to the US. My friends invited me to play football and I learnt all the rules of the game. However, I did not enjoy the game as much as they did because I couldn’t relate to the “culture” behind it. I don’t relate to Super Bowl as much as they did. Nevertheless, it is still a good game to play because I can still win and feel good about it, but the degree of how much I feel is defined by the culture behind it.

Upton, Brian. Aesthetic of Play. Received from https://learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet01-xythos.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/5e00ea752296c/5331553?response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%2A%3DUTF-8%27%27Aesthetic%2520of%2520Play.pdf&response-content-type=application%2Fpdf&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Date=20200202T153629Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=21599&X-Amz-Credential=AKIAZH6WM4PLTYPZRQMY%2F20200202%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Signature=66ee9d40d08a71d31a6e0fe5b5efd2b1eef445620390083ca64e9481d0c70a16

Sarah Vazquez DMS 462 Blog Post #1

The only way to truly interact and engage with a game is to play it.  Before this past week, I have honestly never really given much thought to the action of playing itself, since it seems so fundamental.  The act of playing is pleasant and is the very thing that keeps people interested.  The feeling of playing a game can be something that transcends space and time.  It can create vivid memories of the past, or open people up to revelations about themselves.  Within Homo Ludens it states, “Once played, it endures as a new-found creation of the mind, a treasure to be retained by the memory. It is transmitted, it becomes tradition. I can be repeated at any time… in this faculty of repetition lies one of the most essential qualities of play” (Huizinga, 9 – 10).  This repetitive nature of playing connects to how repetitive certain games can be in our lives.  There are many games that throughout the years I will always cherish and even go back to them for another play through. Over time as I go back to old games, I realize how much I’ve grown and changed throughout my life.  In a way, as I replay a game, I am being shown evidence of my growth as a person.  Although the old games I play have this sense of familiarity, it is also mixed in with a slightly new experience.  An example would be this game I use to play when I was young called Kameo.  Within this game there are enemies called Shadow Trolls and when I was young, I use to be so terrified to fight them that I would sometimes have to have my mom help me.  I recently replayed this game and when coming up against those same enemies, they weren’t that scary at all!  There are even some puzzles in that game that I use to struggle with figuring out.  Now I breeze through them with little challenge.  It is a bittersweet experience but one that shows me evidence of my growth.  I believe that the more we play in our lives, or the more games we go back to, the more apparent our personal growth becomes to us.

Works Cited

Huizinga, Johan. Homo Ludens: a Study of the Play Element in Culture. Angelico Press, 2016.

 

DMS 462 Discussion Post 1-Cydney T

Our discussion this week on Robert Ebert’s opinion as video games not being art is one I wanted to continue discussing in the discussion post. He discusses the different definitions of art and explains that he believes games cannot be art because they can be won but the other forms of expression he considers art “can only be experienced” (Ebert, 2010). This led to the obvious question: What is a video game other than an experience? Not only can games be an experience but can also be a particularly unifying one. People who make games are carefully crafting a balance of incentives and rules with whatever platform (digital, cards etc) to create a human experience that can be spread and enjoyed. Any definition of art that does not include the delicate creation of games is not one that I would refer to. Art is all about the human experience and how it is expressed to other humans. Anything at all that is used to express the agony and joy of conscious existence is art, whether it be ancient paintings of cave walls or the character models in a video game. 

I found that Brian Upton’s piece about the definition of a game and the idea of what play really is, supports the argument that I made above. In “The Aesthetic of Play” Upton wrote about how games had the special ability to transcend cross-cultural boundaries and allow a uniquely crafted experience to spread amongst many populations. He explains that games are essentially a set of boundaries (rules) with freedom to move around within those boundaries. As Upton explains his way into this definition, we see the complexity and great variety that comes with games and how they function and can change over time from person to person. The elaborate intricacy of games and the immense diversity of how they operate is artful within itself. Humans are complicated creatures with endless ways to express themselves and share experiences with each other. There is absolutely no doubt in my mind that the complex idea of play is included in what is to be considered art. 

Works Cited:

Ebert, Robert. 2010. Video Games Can Never Be Art. Received from http://www.rogerebert.com/rogers-journal/video-games-can-never-be-art


Upton, Brian. Aesthetic of Play. Received from https://learn-us-east-1-prod-fleet01-xythos.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/5e00ea752296c/5331553?response-content-disposition=inline%3B%20filename%2A%3DUTF-8%27%27Aesthetic%2520of%2520Play.pdf&response-content-type=application%2Fpdf&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Date=20200202T024633Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=21600&X-Amz-Credential=AKIAZH6WM4PLTYPZRQMY%2F20200202%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Signature=b63d1ddd895ef2624917be0cc9687d93844ef84ea808ca49b5820b84c64a14f3

Redentor Jimenez’s Game Design Blog Post 1

I find “Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference”, by Audre Lorde an interesting essay. What drew my attention was when Ms. Lorde talks about how “by ignoring the past, we are encouraged to repeat its mistakes” when talking about discrimination in our society (p. 117). Over the winter break, I took an African Americans Studies online course and I had to talk about this topic. Some colleges don’t even offer a lot of cultural studies courses; that is not the direction that we should be going. We would need to learn about different things, such as other beliefs, sex, race, social statuses, and age to have a better understanding of our world.

Another interesting quote that Ms. Lorde said, is “as white women ignore their built-in privilege of whiteness and define woman in terms of their own experience alone, then women of Color become “other,” the outsider whose experience and tradition is too “alien” (p, 117) to comprehend. I find this part to be one of the most important statements in this essay. White women who are middle to upper class don’t have to worry about things as compared to African Americans in the lower class. For instance, a younger white woman who lives with her parents who have money to spend would have a different mentality than an African American woman who lives with her parents that can barely pay the bills each month. These sorts of standards are given to these women whether they like it or not. Another great example of white privilege would be white women are more likely to be hired for certain jobs than African American women. Fox News always ceases to amaze me how they have more white women anchors on their stations than African American women.

I believe by having a better understanding of others, we can minimize discrimination (specifically towards women who are lesbian and/or of Color) in our society. In the last paragraph of Ms. Lorde’s essay, she said, that “change means growth, and growth can be painful. But we sharpen self-definition by exposing the self in work and struggle together with those whom we define as different from ourselves, although sharing the same goals” (p. 123). We don’t live in this world to be judgmental of others, but for experience and learning from what we know.

Work Cited Page

Audre Lorde, “Age, Race, Class and Sex: Women Redefining Difference,” in Sister Outsider: Essays and Speeches (Freedom, CA: Crossing Press, 1984), pp. 114 – 123.

Welcome to DMS 462!

Throughout the semester we will use this blog to brainstorm new ideas, conduct game analyses, and share our design progress with each other. Remember, you must post a total of 10 blogs throughout the semester.