DMS 462 Blog Post #2

                This week we went through some board games as examples and inspiration for our upcoming solo project, as well as learning more about procedural rhetoric and structure of games. On Tuesday we were assigned to bring in our own preferred board games and play them in groups. My group played Secret Hitler, a game I was already familiar with, but very refreshing to have new players explore and interact with. The goal is to have the Fascist players elect their Hitler player as chancellor, and the opposing team, Liberals, must prevent it. However, only the fascists know whose roles others have, so it’s up to the Liberals to form trusts and figure identities. While we had fun playing it a few times, we also discussed what the procedural rhetoric is and what mechanic/rule we can try adding in to make it different. We figured the procedural rhetoric was lying to win. As players, we can’t blindly trust others just because they made one favorable move or believe everything they claim. Only through interaction and communication can either sides can win, and that’s what makes it so intense and entertaining. One mechanic we added was the liberals can force someone to reveal their role after gaining enough power, which benefits them greatly since they know if that person is on their side or not. We chose this new mechanic because we felt the liberals were at a disadvantage having fewer liberal cards than fascists to gain power. Another thing I really enjoyed about this is that the board game requires players to also interact with other rather than with just pieces or dice. It adds a whole new mechanic that we can manipulate, and it’s not bound to the board and objects. A lot of factors are introduced, such as people’s personality, deception, persuasion, intimidation, and much more. The more we attempted the game, the more chaotic and confident we were, and it becomes an enjoyable experience.

                On Thursday we went over more about the designs and forms of games. After reading through Tracy Fulleton’s book The Structure of Games, we listed down certain elements and structures all games should have and what creators should think about. Things like what certain playstyle and players you want in your game, the objectives, rules, progression, and outcome. All these matters the most as it’s like a groundwork or to-do list for any game. Looking back at the board games we played last class and every other game I’ve tried, they were all enjoyable because of the same interest other players had, the rules and mechanics kept everyone on the same page, and the designs were very unique and creative.

(Nick Good) Week 3 – How to make a Tabletop Fun

This week, we talked a lot about our first project, which will require us to create our first game from scratch. To begin the week, we found what makes a tabletop game fun by trying out a few different games for ourselves. While trying out these games, we were tasked with thinking about the Fullerton chapter, “The Structure of Games”, and how these games can put a message or idea into the players’ heads. “Procedural Rhetoric” exists in every game, whether that be in a video game or in tabletop games, yet this message can be quite subtle while getting wrapped up in a tabletop game. A video game make its messages quite obvious through dialogue and gameplay, but some board games weave their notions into gameplay, making them so minute that they become invisible to the naked eye (in most cases, a game like Monopoly makes it message quite clear). On top of thinking about Procedural Rhetoric, we also took a shot at designing small games on the fly. It illustrated to me that games made on the spot can be fun for a short burst of entertainment, however, creating a game with replayability and long lasting appeal requires a lot more time for execution. I have been witness to many projects being created in the tabletop world, as I have funded numerous card and board games on Kickstarter, and the process of even coming to a solid idea can take months of testing and thought. I was a bit overwhelmed by this juncture at first, but an idea came to me for a card game, as if by magic during class one day. I immediately had to write it down in my Discord server for my friends to see, so we could discuss what the game could be like. The idea spawned from something me and my friends have been doing quite a lot recently for fun, making tier lists. Tier lists originate with fighting games such as “Street Fighter”, “Mortal Kombat”, and “Super Smash Bros.”, but have become popular to create for all sorts of topics, such as with foods and places, by the YouTube community. My friends and I could get pretty heated making these tier lists, arguing over which ride at Disney was the best, or why grapes were objectively better than apples. This is where the idea came to me, conflict can be a huge part of tabletop games, and making tier lists create lots of conflict. What if I were to explore the idea of making a tier list card game, where argument and personal opinion are in the forefront? It seems the most important part of the design of games is the initial concepts, and I hope to explore some more of my ideas in the future.

DMS 462 Blog Post#3 – Pang Yen Wu

On Thursday’s lecture, we brain storm about the topic we want to do for our individual project. I come up with an idea from a parable in the bible. It’s called the parable of the wandering sheep, it’s from Matthew 18:10-14 

10“See that you do not despise one of these little ones. For I tell you that their angels in heaven always see the face of my Father in heaven. [11] a12“What do you think? If a man owns a hundred sheep, and one of them wanders away, will he not leave the ninety-nine on the hills and go to look for the one that wandered off? 13And if he finds it, truly I tell you, he is happier about that one sheep than about the ninety-nine that did not wander off. 14In the same way your Father in heaven is not willing that any of these little ones should perish.

So I take the idea from the parable Jesus speaks. It’s easier to let people understand the character of God through parable. God is the shepherd, we are the sheep, and satan try to kill the sheep’s. The message I try to convey to the player through the game is, God’s love is unconditional, if he have 100 street sheep, he will leave the 99 sheeps and try to find the one lost sheep back.

So the game play is similar to a board game called Secret Hilter, they have two parties one is called Fascist the other one is called Liberal, in my game it’s God and Satan. For God’s side to win you need to save all the sheeps, for Satan side to win you just need to kill one sheep.

One question I encounter right now is, how to make this game balance, either you have special card for god’s side example: prayer, devotional time, or in other sense I got the idea from the game called queers in love at the end of the world, the main message of that game is try to let the player feel that there in only 10 seconds left to make a decision. For my game there is a message I want to convey to the player too, God is overpower Satan, but at the same time God has more responsibility, he needs to save every sheep. I could have two choice, either design the game make it balance and we could play fairly, or I could just make the game unbalance, unfair to clearly show the player the message of “God overpower Satan”.

Shijia Zheng Blog 2

While many video games exist today where the themes and rhetorics can be easily found in its narrative, the mechanics of games can also be a key factor in deriving rhetoric. In class, we played a variety of board and card games where themes can be derived from the mechanics. For example, my group and I played a Bob Ross game where it emphasized completing paintings quickly and having possession of a variety of art supplies as vehicles towards gaining victory. Thus, it is easy to derive from the game themes emphasizing the importance of speed and resource control. 

In addition, while most analogue games lack an active story with fleshed out characters to derive emotional stakes from, players will still find themselves invested emotionally during playtime. Players will experience both positive and negative emotions from events that happen in the game, usually events that set them back or put them ahead. These emotions are triggered by the mechanics of the games.

Games exhibit structures where each component of its structure is interrelated to other components (Fullerton, 42). As such, while video games can have more fleshed out narratives, I believe that more effort can be put into a lot of these video games where the mechanics are more interrelated to the narrative. The mechanics of a video game should be able to express the themes of the game’s premise as well as the narrative that surrounds it. In some games, I feel that narrative acts more like icing on the top rather than something that is baked into the structure of the game, such as games where the majority of storytelling is relayed through cutscenes. There also seems to be a lot of games where having the narrative take center-place means having simplified gameplay. This can be seen in games dubbed “walking simulators.” 

While I don’t think every game needs complex mechanics, I think it could still be exciting to see a game where the gameplay mechanics also express elements of the narrative and vice-versa. In board and card games, I feel that, while the narrative that surrounds them are more simplistic, the narrative is baked into the mechanics of the games themselves, while I think the opposite is more common in video games. 

Sources:Fullerton, Tracy. “The Structure of Games.” Game Design Workshop: A Playcentric Approach to Creating Innovative Games, 4th ed.

DMS 462 Blog Post #3 – Timothy Harianja

This week we explore more about the structure of games and their procedural rhetoric through reading Fullerton’s book and playing games in class. In her book, The Structure of Games, Tracy Fullerton describes about the underlying structure that all games usually have. In her book, she lists all the elements that games usually have which include players, objectives, procedures, rules, resources, conflict, boundaries, and outcome (Fullerton, 32-38). In this blog, I want to focus mostly on players, procedures and rules. What distinguish between games and other forms of media is player. Players are required in games and due to this, users of games are more active compare to users of other media. Procedures and rules are also important because all other elements of games rely on them. Without procedures and rules, the game can’t have a good outcome, game play, and become meaningless in a sense.

We also talk about procedural rhetoric, how rules and procedures can have meanings and lessons behind them. On Tuesday, I was playing Secret Hitler. This game is similar to Werewolf in which deception and persuasion are key to winning the game. Secret Hitler can teach people that persuasive speaking or speech can convince someone to believe something that wasn’t convincing in the first place. It also have some aspect of luck in it, for example, each player will either be a liberal or a fascist and in each turn a player will have to draw 3 cards and choose 2 cards out of the 3 for another player to choose from. Those cards can be either liberal or fascist. In short, a liberal would want to choose a liberal card out of the 2 cards given to him/her, thus it would be unlucky for a liberal player to draw 3 fascist cards. The procedural rhetoric of the games shows that there are aspects that we cannot control. Sometimes, we already know who the Hitler is and know how to win the match, but we simply can’t win due to these unlucky draws. This is also true in our daily life too. We can make wise decisions but essentially these aspects are out of our control.

I guess all of these above allow me to have a better grasp of the structure of games and use that understanding for the solo project. The most important questions to ask are: how do players engage in the games? what are the rules? are they balanced and making sense? Is the procedural rhetoric relevant to certain audience?

Procedural Rhetoric and the Iterative Process #3

Procedural rhetoric is the recurring concept within games that has been iterated over and over. It’s similar to asking what makes this game tick. There is a reason behind every game and a way to proceed through that game to one goal. Fullerton explains this as a few components, which are as follows. The procedure is the process of getting to the goal. The rules restrict the player. Finally the resources help advance or benefit the player on their way to their goal. Although there are more than just these pieces to the puzzle, I found that these three envelop a large portion of procedural rhetoric.

Through class, the objective while playing each game was to understand its procedural rhetoric. Some games wanted you to gain points or find out an enemy, but rules and resources deterred the player from accomplishing their goal with ease. Every structure all came down to the player, again and again. The player is given rules and mechanics that enhance and challenge them so that they are entertained on the way to the goal. However, balance determines if that game is truly fun. As rules were altered in the games during class, we found that one change could completely unbalance that game, making it almost unplayable even though that change seemed like a good idea beforehand. This problem displayed the issue that will be coming up during the game development stages. It shows us that if a new addition or change does not work then we must return to the drawing board and start again. So, the iterative process, that Fullerton mentions, is displayed as generating ideas, formalizing ideas, testing ideas, and evaluating ideas, are all apparent in this exercise, which supports his idea.

Overall, procedural rhetoric not only helps us understand the inner workings of a game, but it also provides us with insight that can be utilized in the iterative process. Components of a game’s procedural rhetoric are changed, which in turn are put through a testing cycle. The work done in class supports these functions and provides a better comprehension of procedural rhetoric.

Works Cited

Fullerton, Tracy. Game Design Workshop: a Playcentric Approach to Creating Innovative Games. CRC Press, 2019.

Gillian Marcus Blog Post 2

In Tracy Fullerton’s The Structure of Games, Fullerton discusses the similarities between games and what exactly it even means to be one.  She compares games to other media and explains a very important difference between the two: when it comes to games, the player is actively involved and has some sort of influence on the outcome.  You can choose what you want to do when you’re playing a game. However, with regards to media, it is the opposite: the player has more of a passive role and doesn’t have an influence on the outcome.  Another feature of games that Fullerton discusses is objective. The contrast between games and media is again stated: with media, characters still have objectives, but the viewer does not. With games, the player does have specific objectives.  Along with player involvement and objectives, Fullerton further goes on to discuss what else truly makes a game, including procedures and rules. Rules are the structure to a game that state what a player can or cannot do, which we discussed in class.  On Tuesday, I found it very interesting when we created/modified one rule to the board game that we were playing in class. It completely changed the game we were playing, which only goes to show how important rules really are. As soon as you change them up, the game becomes something entirely different.  Rules are what make games unique.

Later on, Fullerton discusses player engagement in games, including detailed stories and concepts.  This is incredibly important when it comes to board games, video games, etc., because without the players, there would be no game.  Far too many games that have had great potential have ended up not being successful due to lack of player engagement from the creators.  We see this a lot in video games where the developers become uninterested or don’t have enough funding to improve concepts / fix bugs that the community complains about.  All in all, it becomes clear that to make a good game, you must be able to appropriately engage your players and make them want to come back for more. After reading this chapter, I definitely became more aware of the specific structure games have, so much so to the point where you could even find a similarity between Go Fish and Quake (a first person shooter).

Fullerton, Tracy, Game Design Workshop: A Playcentric Approach to Creating Innovative Games, Fourth Edition, 2019

Discussion Post 2-Cydney T

Our activities this week with card and board games really put an emphasis on the delicate balance of all the parts of a game that is required for an optimal gaming experience. Fullerton points out these different parts in the reading: players, objectives, procedures, rules, resources, boundaries and outcome (Fullerton, 2019). It was interesting to see this played out while playing games in class and changing one of the rules. In my first game, Exploding Kittens, we changed some of the rules that took away elements of fairness and made the game more chaotic and frustrating. 

It is also very interesting to see how different analog games get players to be more invested with the premise of the game. While this is typically easier to point out in video games, with board and card games it is sometimes more subtle. Fullerton describes that “The base-level e ect of the premise is to make it easier for players to contextualize their choices, but it’s also a powerful tool for involving players emotionally in the interaction of the formal elements” (Fullerton, 2019 pg 45). I found the premise of Secret Hitler to be especially effective in this area. It took the historical context of the rise of fascism and political contexts and turned it into an immersive experience within a game full of strategy and deceit. 

I hope to effectively incorporate this balance in my first project where I plan to combine the rules of fairly basic traditional games (checkers and original card games like war) and a more immersive premise and/or story behind the set of rules and mechanics in the game. It seems to be more difficult to do so with analog games considering you cannot animate characters and add dialogue to tell a story, but some games have achieved quite engaging player experiences with analog games (such as Secret Hitler, Midnight Ultimate Werewolf, Betrayal at House on the Hill, Coup, etc). I am hoping to achieve a medieval aesthetic with my design that will play into the already seemingly royal nature of traditional playing cards and combine it with rules that set up a procedural rhetoric reflecting upon the political actions of medieval times. 

Works Cited:
Fullerton, Tracy. Game Design Workshop: A Playcentric Approach to Creating Innovative Games, 4th Edition. 2019.

Game Design Workshop: Chapter 2 Response – Redentor Jimenez

Chapter 2, The Structure of Games, from the Game Design Workshop textbook, by Tracy Fullerton, is an interesting read. The chapter first starts out by talking about how the games, Go Fish and Quake have similarities and differences. At first, I thought they would have more differences, but while reading through the chapter I noticed that it was not the case. Both games actually have a lot in common. The most generic similarity is that both games are designed for players. Go Fish and Quake both have objectives, which you are aiming to achieve. Go Fish’s objective is to have the most “books” (4 of a kind) than everyone else. Quake’s objective is “to stay alive and complete the level of the complex you are in” (Fullerton p. 34). Whether you are playing Go Fish or Quake, there are rules that the players have to follow. In Go Fish, if someone asks for a card and you have it, you can’t just say “Go Fish” (it means I do not have the card). You need to play by the rules and give the person the card they asked for. In Quake you have to use certain ammunition for certain guns. Even if you wanted to use ammunition from a different type of gun, the game’s code will prevent you from doing so. Boundaries are formed in both games, so players do not move outside specific boundaries. In “Go Fish, the boundaries are more conceptual than physical.” (Fullerton p. 37). Players are agreeing that they are going playing the game and will not leave the game once they start it. In Quake, some walls prevent you from going out of bounce.

After reading chapter 2, it amazes me how games can seem completely different but yet have a lot of similarities to them. This chapter made me realize that to be a good game designer, it is extremely important in having great organization and communication skills. Without these skills, parts of a game may suffer because of it. Two great examples of horrible game design are Anthem, by BioWare and Fallout 76, by Bethesda. The structure of both of these games is unbalanced and unfinished to be considered a playable and polished game for a consumer.

Fullerton, Tracy. Game Design Workshop: A Playcentric Approach to Creating Innovative Games Fourth Edition. Taylor & Francis Group, 2019.

Diversity: From Call of Duty to Apex Legends

In Class last Tuesday, we dissected Audre Lorde’s article, “Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference.” One piece of Lorde’s article that stood out to me was the idea of a mythical norm, an idea or state that people perceive the “regular” or “average” person to be. The ones that do not share the qualities of the mythical norm are considered different. Lorde mentions that the american norm is classified as “white, thin, male, young, heterosexual, christian and financialy stable,” (Lorde pg. 116). 

When I think of the idea of a mythical norm, my first thought went to Jason West and Vince Zampella. These two are the co-founders of Infinity Ward and are responsible for creating the Call of Duty series. The mythical norm can be seen clearly with this series’ protagonists, as most games involve a young, thin, white male main character fighting the evil organization that happens to be in that particular game. In 2010, West and Zampella left Infinity Ward to create Respawn Entertainment, who are the developers behind the Titanfall series and Apex Legends. 

Since the creation of Apex Legends, West and Zampella have tried to make their games as inclusive as possible. The roster in Apex Legends is very diverse, consisting of two women of color with Bangalore and Lifeline, a non-binary character with Bloodhound, and an openly gay man with Gibraltar. As Apex Legends continues to grow and add more characters, we will continue to see more diversity and representation within the game.

Although the idea of a mythical norm is still present in video games, There are games that try to be inclusive and break that idea. I hope that future developers follow in Respawn Entertainment’s footsteps and create a cast of characters that is diverse, lively, and fun to interact with.

Works Cited:

Lorde, Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference, Sister Outsider, 2016